Chapter 15:Research and Evaluation Skills

Home

Alternative Approaches | Purpose of Evaluation | Who Will Evaluate | Report Methods | Supervisors Role | Teacher's Evaluation | Achievement Tests | Summary
Alternative Approaches

Alternative approaches to research and evaluation.

  • Research on and evaluation of instructional programs is based on two broad approaches.

a) Quanitative - Numerical way of measuring classroom events and objectives.

b)Qualitative - Narrative reporting

  • These two approaches are based on different conceptions.
    • Quanitative and qualitative research compared by a number of scholars discussing relations to critical research issues. 
    • Nature of Reality and Knowledge
      • Quanitative assumes there is a single external reality
      • Qualitative assumes that the world consists of multiple realities that are constructed by individuals or groups. 
    • Goals or Research
      • Quanitative - To identify relationships between variables.
      • Qualitative - To describe phenomenons from the perspective of participants.
    • Researcher's Role
      • Quanitative - Assumes the role of the detached observer (as little interaction with subject as possible)
      • Qualitative - Involves intentionally
    • Importance of Context
      • Quanitative - Phenomenon can and should be studied seperate from context.
      • Qualitative - Phenomenon is greatly influenced by it's context (they must be studied together)
    • Values in Research
      • Quanitative - Value free
      • Qualitative - Describe values and their effects
    • Cause and Effect
      • Quanitative - Effect has preceding cause
      • Qualitative - Variables are mutually and simultaneously affect each other
  • Can These Two Methods be Used in the Same Study
    • Experts believe that the two methods are compatible, and that the best studies combine the two approaches.
  • Judgement
    • How do we know out instructional programs are successful?
    • Should we continue with the same curriculum and grouping practices?
    • Evaluating is the act of making a judgement.